Dog sniff unconstitutional? Supreme Court rules drug dog sniffs constitute illegal search

array(2) { [0]=> string(0) "" ["keywords"]=> string(17) "constitute,Court," }

Dog : Justice Antonin Scalia said a person has the Fourth Amendment right to be free from the government’s gaze inside their home and in the area surrounding it, which is called the curtilage.

By Jesse J. Holland, Associated Press / March 26, 2013

The ruled Tuesday that police cannot bring -sniffing police dogsonto a suspect’s property to look for evidence without first getting a warrant for a , a decision which may limit how investigators use ’ sensitive noses to search out drugs, explosives and other items hidden from human sight, sound and smell.

Skip to next paragraph

The high court split 5-4 on the decision to uphold the Florida Supreme Court’s ruling throwing out evidence seized in the search of Joelis Jardines’ Miami-area house. That search was based on an alert by Franky the drug dog from outside the closed front door.

Justice Antonin Scalia said a person has the Fourth Amendment right to be free from the government’s gaze inside their home and in the area surrounding it, which is called the curtilage.

“The police cannot, without a warrant based on probable cause, hang around on the lawn or in the side garden, trawling for evidence and perhaps peering into the windows of the home,” Justice Antonin Scalia said for the majority. “And the officers here had all four of their feet and all four of their companion’s, planted firmly on that curtilage — the front porch is the classic example of an area intimately associated with the life of the home.”

He was joined in his opinion by Justices Clarence Thomas, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan.

On the morning of Dec. 5, 2006, Miami-Dade police detectives and U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration agents set up surveillance outside a house south of the city after getting an anonymous tip that it might contain a marijuana growing operation. Detective Douglas Bartelt arrived with Franky and the two went up to the house, where Franky quickly detected the odor of pot at the base of the front door and sat down as he was trained to do.

That sniff was used to get a search warrant from a judge. The house was searched and its lone occupant, Jardines, was arrested trying to escape out the back door. Officers pulled 179 live marijuana plants from the house, with an estimated street value of more than $ 700,000.

Jardines was charged with marijuana trafficking and grand theft for stealing electricity needed to run the highly sophisticated operation. He pleaded not guilty and his attorney challenged the search, claiming Franky’ssniff outside the front door was an unconstitutional law enforcement intrusion into the home.

The trial judge agreed and threw out the evidence seized in the search, but that was reversed by an intermediate appeals court. In April a divided Florida Supreme Court sided with the original judge.

The Supreme Court’s decision upholds that ruling.

“A drug detection dog is a specialized device for discovering objects not in plain view (or plain smell),” Kagan wrote in a concurring opinion. “That device here was aimed at a home — the most private and inviolate (or so we expect) of all the places and things the Fourth Amendment protects. Was this activity a trespass? Yes, as the court holds today. Was it also an invasion of privacy? Yes, that as well.”

The four justices who dissented were Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Stephen Breyer, Justice Anthony Kennedy and Justice Samuel Alito.

It’s not trespassing when a mail carrier comes on a porch for a brief period, Alito said. And that includes “police officers who wish to gather evidence against an occupant,” Alito said. “According to the court, however, the police officer in this case, Detective Bartelt, committed a trespass because he was accompanied during his otherwise lawful visit to the front door of the respondent’s house by his dog, Franky. Where is the authority evidencing such a rule?”

Alito also said that the court’s ruling stretches expectations of privacy too far.

“A reasonable person understands that odors emanating from a house may be detected from locations that are open to the public, and a reasonable person will not count on the strength of those odors remaining within the range that, while detectable by a dog, cannot be smelled by a human.”

dog – Yahoo! News Search Results


You May Also Like These Topics...

7 Best Calming Solutions for Dogs with Separation Anxiety

array(2) { [0]=> string(0) "" ["keywords"]=> string(31) ",," }

1. Kong Wobbler A lot of dog owners have reported positive results using a Kong Wobbler. The toy is designed to be filled with dog treats or kibble. The design makes it virtually impossible for your dog to get the treats out of the toy, which can help prevent separation anxiety. It takes a little […]

How Long Does It Take For Your Dog To Settle In Your New Home?

array(2) { [0]=> string(0) "" ["keywords"]=> string(29) "Animal Welfare,," }

Relocating to a new house is a whole lot of work, especially when you are doing it all by yourself. This includes going through an adjustment period, where you will feel the need to adapt to the new environment and other factors. Just like humans, our furry friends also need to have some time to […]

10 Small Hypoallergenic Dog Breeds that don’t Bark

array(2) { [0]=> string(0) "" ["keywords"]=> string(33) ",Affenpinscher Dogs," }

Welcoming a pet into your home as a friend for a lifetime Is always a dreamy milestone to achieve. But if you are someone who starts to show allergic reactions as soon as you come in contact with the pet, then this dreamy situation can turn into a Nightmare. So, if you are facing this […]

Paw Print Jewelry is the Purr-fect Choice for Pet Owners

array(2) { [0]=> string(0) "" ["keywords"]=> string(22) ",Charm," }

Recent estimates indicate that approximately 90 million dogs – and close to 100 million cats – have a home in the United States. When it comes to their pets, animal lovers spare no expense in caring for their pet or showcasing their love for man’s best friends. But don’t let that last statement fool you […]

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,
Previous Post
file000188823032.jpg
Article - Sponsored

Math Homework in the Classroom?

Next Post
file0001214633496.jpg
Dog Accessories

Duck Tutu Dog Dress

Leave a Reply

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin